In a 2018 interview Williams' mother, Marcia Williams, said his children struggled without their father, particularly his eldest child. Williams is described as Black, 5 feet 8 inches tall and 160 pounds with brown eyes and brown hair. All evidence points to her husband who was having a 14 year affair that involved property ownership with his mistress. The suit alleges Calkins . Source: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Disappearance_of_Terrance_Williams_and_Felipe_Santos 462 123 123 comments Best Add a Comment bz237 6 yr. ago Calkins had long been silent on the disappearances. Neither man has been seen or heard from since. ClutzyMe, Pregnant Brooklyn college student missing since 1998, last seen with the father of her childalso her professorwho wanted her to have an abortion (she refused). yarrowflax. The other candidates are invited to respond to sets of questions as well. When somebody goes missing and theyre a blue-eyed, blonde woman, theyre all over the news, he said. Flores allegedly stated that he and Kristin went their separate ways on the night of her disappearance, each going to their own dorm rooms. No body, no case. Lived with scumbag boyfriend after leaving strict conservative upbringing. Neither man has been seen or heard from since." ClutzyMe The sheriffs office says the incident has []. 2, 2021 7:30 am700d ago, Trish Mehaffey Crime and Courts Mar. When he allegedly called Circle K, he came to know that Terrance did not work there. Denson, now 30, made the tearful declaration during Thursdays news conference, where Hollywood heavyweight Tyler Perry and the Rev. was cited by Collier County deputy Steve Calkins for . A Collier County sheriff's deputy prevailed in litigation filed by the family of a man who vanished 17 years ago, shortly after a roadside interaction with the deputy. The arbitrator, Robert E. Doyle Jr., ruled the plaintiffs' arguments lacked evidence to show Calkins' acts led to Williams' disappearance. Both men were last seen being arrested by Steve Calkins, then a deputy in the Collier County Sheriff's Department, for driving without a license. In an audio recording of a call the officer then made to dispatch to have the car removed as a traffic hazard, the legal filing says, Calkins made numerous racial stereotype remarks about what kind of person could own the Cadillac he staged as abandoned. Two women, just 20 and 22 years old, lost their lives in an overnight crash. After Calkins had the vehicle towed, he performed a warrants check on Williams, according to the lawsuit. They were all buddies. We reached out to Williams mother about the decision, who referred us to her attorney. Steven Calkins is set to be deposed Tuesday as part of a civil wrongful death suit filed in 2018 by the mother of Terrance Williams on behalf of his estate. My mom was deeply upset and went to the cops a few times for records, trying to push the case, got blown off. Alex Murdaugh sentenced to life in prison for murders of wife and son, Biden had cancerous skin lesion removed last month, doctor says, White supremacist and Holocaust denier Nick Fuentes kicked out of CPAC, Tom Sizemore, actor known for "Saving Private Ryan" and "Heat," dies at 61, Biden team readies new advisory panel ahead of expected reelection bid, At least 10 dead after winter storm slams South, Midwest, House Democrats unhappy with White House handling of D.C.'s new criminal code. No one pursued it and dude just dipped town. Sure its possible she was abducted elsewhere, but the fact is she was incapacitated and with those three men, then never seen again. the_expert_jd. How much should your insurance company pay, and can an adjuster stack on costs? Calkins was fired following an internal. Perry offered a $100,000 reward which has since doubled for information in the decade-old case of the two men, who went missing after separate encounters with Collier County Sheriff's Deputy Steven Calkins. They even ended up asking how (boyfriend) was. A 15-year-old boy has been arrested and is being charged with the shooting death of another teen at the DeSoto County Fair. My God, its long overdue that he answers questions, Crump said, standing next to Terrance Williams mother, Marcia. And since hes not been prosecuted for that, then, there can be a prosecution later on.. This lawsuit is going to formally say what people for the last 14 years have been informally saying, that he intentionally murdered Terrance Williams and Felipe Santos.. The first two episodes of the series are dedicated to the Williams and Santos story, and are narrated and executive produced by filmmaker and actor Tyler Perry, who became involved in the case after seeing a TV report about it. The case was supposed to be heading to trial, but the attorneys representing the family forgot to file the motion for trial in time, so that means the arbitrators decision is now final. Privacy Policy. By accepting all cookies, you agree to our use of cookies to deliver and maintain our services and site, improve the quality of Reddit, personalize Reddit content and advertising, and measure the effectiveness of advertising. It turns out a tow company did indeed pick up Terrance's white Cadillac at the Naples Memorial Gardens Cemetery on January 12. You will begin to receive our Daily Courts & Public Safety updates. The sheriff's office partnered with the U.S. Attorney's Office, Florida Department of Law Enforcement and the FBI to investigate Calkins, the former sheriff has said, but law enforcement has been unable to solve the longstanding mystery. Calkins told investigators he also took Williams to a Circle K and dropped him off, instead of arresting him, the lawsuit states. The week before the murder, he had bought lime, big trash bags, shovels, a silencer, rifle bullets. last year against Steven Calkins. The idea of suing for wrongful death, which has already happened, thats over and done, said attorney Pamella Seay, an FGCU justice studies professor. Through his attorney, Calkins declined an interview request. Both men were last seen in the company of now-fired CCSO deputy Steve Calkins. Students, staff, family, and friends came together on Friday for the annual unified basketball game at Fort Myers High School. Cancel any time on account page or at888-274-5343, effective at the end of the billing cycle. The first season of the new docuseries "Never Seen Again" is available to stream on Paramount+. While no specified timeline is found, he moved to Iowa shortly after being dismissed from the force. Felipe Santos was a 23-year-old undocumented Mexican worker who disappeared in October 2003, three months before Terrance vanished. Jacobs said a virtual interview is not sufficient. According to Florida Highway Patrol, a Ford Escape was going north on US-41 nearing Dixie Road shortly after 10:30 p.m. A Collier County was found guilty Monday morning of burglarizing a home and pawning off the stolen property in 2019. We believe that body language is very important and sitting in a room with someone is very important, Jacobs said. Nothing really has changed from February of 2004 to the filing of this complaint.. Three fellow students escorted Smart back to her hall of residence after a party. Both men were reported missing more than 15 years ago, after last being in contact with former Collier County Sheriff's Office deputy Steven Calkins. When 27-year-old Terrance Williams went missing on January 12, 2004, his mother, Marcia, filed a missing person report. Almost 17 years ago, Williams was last seen at a cemetery after he was pulled over by then deputy Calkins in Collier County. He sleeps every night in his bed peacefully while Marcia and Terrance Williams children havent had a peaceful night of sleep in the last 14 years, and nor has the Santos family.. A white sheriffs deputy murdered two young men he arrested in unrelated traffic stops almost 15 years ago, according to a wrongful death lawsuit filed in Florida this week. One of the biggest issues people are dealing with when it comes to insurance after Hurricane Ian is property damage. It worked. Williams' family filed a wrongful death suit against Calkins in 2018. The lawsuit gained national attention when it was filed because it involved Crump and actor and film director Tyler Perry, who commented on the case on social media and in People magazine, according to the Naples Daily News and other outlets. 2010 The Thought & Expression Company, LLC. Steven Henry Calkins. Zachary Steven Johnson, 33, was found guilty as charged of burglary of a dwelling and two counts of dealing in stolen property after a two-day trial in Collier County. Students, staff, family, and friends came together on Friday for the annual unified basketball game at Fort Myers High School. During this call, Calkins made 'racially insensitive comments about the type of person who owned a 'homie Cadillac, according to the lawsuit. Sharpton put his arm around the man, and a. Marcia filed a complaint against Steve and an internal investigation against him was initiated. Steve Calkins has arrived at the current date at the age of 67, where his accurate date of birth is still missing from the internet. Detectives believe Steven Calkins is the last person to have seen Terrance Williams and Felipe. Calkins is believed to be the last known person to have seen Felipe Santos, 23, an immigrant from Mexico, and Terrance D. Williams, 27, a Black man, both of Naples, according to authorities and the lawsuit. The evidence and the pleadings state that Mr. Calkins killed Mr. if he killed him at all would have killed Mr. Williams no later than February of 2004. He told investigators several different stories about how he received the injury. u/mcwjdw33. Boyfriend was older and abusive. Firefighters are battling several brush fires in Charlotte County; the one off McCall Road threatens several buildings, including a church. "I just want answers for Marcia and the Santos family to know what happened," says Tyler Perry, "I think that's only fair. Read More: Terrance Williams and Felipe Santos: Missing or Found? CCSO says the thieves in recent distraction thefts typically use a ruse to approach senior citizens, usually in grocery store parking lots and remove the victims watch [], Cassandra Smith, accused of killing Charlotte County Deputy Christopher Taylor in a November DUI crash, was denied bond for a second time on Friday. Calkins had picked him up after Williams' car broke down. Corporal Calkins then apparently put Felipe in the patrol car and drove away. No one did anything, not the cops or family. Emotional moments rushed through the crowd like waves as loved ones came to the site where the [], The Collier County Sheriffs Office is investigating a shooting at a Waffle House near Collier Boulevard and I-75. In separate incidents, both men were last seen after having been arrested by Deputy Steve Calkins, who claimed he had "changed his mind" about the arrests and dropped the men off at Circle K convenience stores. She was paying her way through nursing school by dancing at less than reputable establishments. Calkins had picked him up after Williams' car broke down. By Caleb McCullough and Erin Murphy, - Gazette-Lee Des Moines Bureau, Williams' mother, Marcia Williams, filed a wrongful-death lawsuit in 2018, Subscribe to the Public Safety newsletter. Detectives believe Steven Calkins is the last person to have seen Terrance Williams and Felipe Santos alive before they each disappeared 16 years ago. Theyre suing Calkins for wrongful death. The Florida appeals court did not issue an opinion this week but simply affirmed Brodies decision. A civil rights attorney announced Tuesday that he has filed a wrongful death lawsuit against former Collier County Sheriff's deputy Steven Calkins. In December 2020, Crump filed a motion for reconsideration and a new trial but was denied on appeal in January 2022. Both men were declared dead after five years of being missing. (AP Photo/Naples Daily News, William DeShazer). Williams has been missing since that happened. We are confident that the information uncovered will allow the DOJ to keep the investigation of what happened to Terrance active and moving forward to earn justice for his memory and all those who loved him.. And he grew angry when a plaintiff's attorney tried to jog his memory. Get browser notifications for breaking news, live events, and exclusive reporting. Contacted at home by his department's dispatch a few days after Terrance Williams' disappearance, Calkins initially denied having had any interaction with Terrance and even failed to recall towing a Cadillac from the cemetery on January 12. In Naples, city council authorized the city manager to spend up to $100,000 to expedite the cleanup of dead fish within the city waterways []. As more people start to pile into the area, and beaches reopen, the fish kill will become a bigger problem. For example, he said he didn't know Williams' last name but conducted a warrants check with Williams' full name and date of birth. Calkins told investigators he pulled Williams over near a cemetery in NorthNaples because Williams appeared to be having problems with his car. Steve was fired in 2004 on the grounds of being uncooperative with the investigation and providing conflicting statements. A wrongful death lawsuit against a former Collier County deputy returned to court Tuesday. However, Santos was never booked at jail. In separate incidents, both men were last seen after having been arrested by Deputy Steve Calkins, who claimed he had changed his mind about the arrests and dropped the men off at Circle K convenience stores. "I wish I could win the lottery. According to the lawsuit, Steven H. Calkins, now 66, came to Cedar Rapids years after the 2003 and 2004 cases in which two men went missing after being placed in the back of his patrol vehicle. Hooley also pointed out a court order from Jan. 12, 2020, states an arbitration decision would be final if a request for a new trial wasn't filed in time. According to records, Calkins lived in a house in southeast Cedar Rapids in 2014 and purchased a northeast side home in 2016. The case was heard by a court appointed arbitrator, who made a decision against. If you are decent, human, kind person with a soul, I dont know how you cant be upset these two people were put in the back of a sheriffs car, disappeared, and have not been seen for 14 years.. The Guardian left a message seeking comment at a telephone number listed for Calkins in Cedar Rapids, Iowa. They said Calkins returned later and moved Williams car to the side of the road. I as well as many individuals believe Paul Flores may have been involved in her disappearance/murder since he was the last person to see her alive. Hoping that Terrance's Cadillac could provide a lead to his disappearance, Marcia's family tried the town's tow companies. Calkins responded to a minor traffic crash in which Santos was driving. Collier county sheriff's office "Deputy Steve Calkins is 100% responsible. According to Collier County sheriff's reports, both men went missing within three months of each other - Santos on Oct. 14, 2003, and Williams on Jan. 12, 2004 - and under similar circumstances. An investigation led to Calkins being fired from the Collier County Sheriff's Department in the Naples, Fla. area. A fish kill is filling up the water in Southwest Florida. Typically, because arbitration isn't the final word, a plaintiff still can request a jury trial, but Marcia Williams' attorney didn't file a motion. Founded in 2010, Thought Catalog is owned and operated by The Thought & Expression Company, Inc. For over a decade, we've been at the bleeding edge of media, pioneering an infrastructure for creatives to flourish both artistically and financially. Investigators discovered Calkins called a tow truck company for the car and had the towing records sent to himself rather than to Collier County Sheriffs Office. "He was happy to be a father, and his daughter had to grow up without one," saidJulia Perkins, of the Coalition of Immokalee Workers, which advocates for the Santos family in a 2017 interview. One a few minutes later of him saying she shot herself. His stories were so inconsistent, so unbelievable, and even though he had all these inconsistencies there were no charges brought. During those calls, Williams is heard in the background, so at that time Calkins still had Williams in custody but Williams was never booked and never seen again at his home, work or by family members, the lawsuit asserts. Police ruled it a suicide. The lawsuit asserts that Calkins' act or acts caused Williams' disappearance and death. Reddit and its partners use cookies and similar technologies to provide you with a better experience. Its so infuriating that we will never get definitive answers on this, but all signs point to her husband Josh Powell killing her. Steve is presently in his late 60s and still likely living in Cedar Rapids with his loved ones. Williams moved with his family from Chattanooga, Tennessee. I highly recommend Dave Cawleys podcast Cold about the case, even if youre familiar with the case. She was packing a bag one night, supposedly to leave. This article originally appeared on Naples Daily News: Terrance Williams disappearance: case against former deputy denied appeal, What to know about missing Collier men Terrance Williams and Felipe Santos, Ex-deputy tied to Collier missing men Terrance Williams, Felipe Santos prevails in lawsuit, Terrance Williams disappearance: case against former deputy denied appeal. Filmmaker Tyler Perry posted this week about missing Collier County men Terrance Williams and Felipe Santos. He received commendations for helping to lift an overturned pickup off a man who was suffocating underneath. However, it was stated on the show that investigators got hold of the call record where Steve was making a tow request to the dispatch; the recording allegedly contained instances of racial slurs as well as conflicting statements on Steves part. In Naples, city council authorized the city manager to spend up to $100,000 to expedite the cleanup of dead fish within the city waterways []. "You know my biggest wish?" Not even shamed publically, because police withhold his identity. DecadentEx. Also, Flores was noticed having a black eye on the days following Kristins disappearance. Calkins lawyer in Naples, John Hooley, declined to comment on the decision beyond writing in an email: Judge Brodie heard the evidence and reached a conclusion that was upheld on appeal as the proper disposition of the case., In an interview last year, Hooley said about his client: This is not a guy who took Terrance Williams on a one-way ride to the swamp. Hooley, in his motion, asks the court not to grant Williams' motion and leave arbitration as final judgment. I just don't see how that is possible.". As of now, Martha Moxleys murder is technically unsolved. SwissArmyGnat, Walking her two GSDs when she was shot with her own pistol which was then left at the scene. What is equally surprising is that 50% were black men, women and children, so its a dynamic not known to many Americans, he said. Terrance Williams and Felipe Santos went missing in 2004 and 2003 respectively under similar circumstances in Naples Florida U.S. 2023 www.news-press.com. But he has never been criminally charged in connection with the case. We reached out to attorneys on both sides of the lawsuit, and we are still waiting to hear back from them. Judge Geoffrey Gentile denied Smith bond the first time because the November DUI arrest was not the first time law enforcement said she was caught drinking and driving. Both men are presumed dead. Further, he landed out of position . The dogs picked up the scent of a deceased human on the corner of Floress mattress. The civil lawsuit filed on behalf of the victims families claims that the two men Terrance Williams, 27, and Felipe Santos, 24 were taken away in a squad car by Steven Calkins, a Collier county deputy, in January 2004 and October 2003 respectively but never booked into jail. And to this day Deputy Steve Calkins is a free man. During an internal investigation Calkins failed a polygraph test pertaining to contact with Terrance Williams and ultimately refused to cooperate . 5, 2021 7:30 am698d ago, Tom Barton, Quad-City Times Business News Apr. COVID-19 has made that difficult. Tyler Perry posts about Collier disappearances of minority men last seen with ex-deputy, Attorneys for Terrance Williams' estate given 20 days to amend complaint against ex-Collier deputy, Ex-deputy thought to be last to see two men in Collier contests wrongful-death lawsuit, Former CCSO deputy faces civil lawsuit in decade-old disappearances of 2 Collier men, Missing Collier men Terrance Williams, Felipe Santos remembered at ceremony, Your California Privacy Rights/Privacy Policy. Terrance Williams and Felipe Santos went missing in 2004 and 2003, respectively, under . Offer expires 5/17/22. For Marcia Williams, the story of her son's disappearance is about to get more complicated. The suit states Calkins moved to Iowa sometime after being fired, but it was unclear when he relocated to Cedar Rapids. Collier County sheriff's deputy Steve Calkins claimed both times to have changed his mind and left each of them at a different Circle K convenience store nearby. Now, the only way this case sees a courtroom is if criminal charges are filed. An arbitrator found the case didn't show Calkins in a 'good light, based on his inconsistent statements to law enforcement and that he didn't cooperate in the investigation, but the evidence was mostly circumstantial. These two young men disappeared off the face of the earth and the last man to see them was this deputy. Calkins also was the last person seen with Felipe Santos, an illegal . Family of missing man in Collier County ruled against in wrongful death lawsuit, Winds stoke brush fires and prompt evacuations across Southwest Florida, Fort Myers High School hosts annual unified basketball game, Public adjuster answers your hurricane-related property insurance questions, What the number of winter shorebirds means for Florida, Crash kills a man crossing street in Collier County Friday night, Collier County man found guilty of burglarizing home, pawning stolen TVs, Nonprofit building hurricane-resistant housing for low-income families in Collier County, 15-year-old arrested in death at DeSoto County Fair: Whats wrong with the world today?, How bloodless open heart surgeries are performed, North Naples woman arrested after dog dies trapped in vehicle, After Hurricane Ian, Lee County reopening beach parks with free parking, Public memorial for Fort Myers Police Chief Derrick Diggs. Lent him close to $100k. recalls Marcia, "And I'm like, 'Oh my God, they found my baby, they found my baby!' The suit also cites other actions that day: Calkins didn't call or radio dispatchers that he initiated the traffic stop of Williams, according to sheriff's reports. . In a Jan. 10, 2013, file photo, Collier County (Fla.) Sheriff Kevin Rambosk, at lectern, speaks at a news conference to discuss the special missing-person investigations of Terrance Williams and Felipe Santos. Listening, from left, are NAACP President Ben Jealous, filmmaker Tyler Perry, and Marcia Williams, the mother of Terrance Williams. Crump's team is now hoping to use Calkins' deposition to get the federal Department of Justice's Civil Rights Division to reopen the investigation. The Williams family countered, saying they couldnt file the lawsuit until after the state issued a death certificate. The Calkins team argued the Williams family failed to file the wrongful death lawsuit two years after Williams disappeared as required by law. Powered by WordPress.com VIP. His supervisors asked him for an incident report wherein he stated that he saw Terrances car in distress at around 12:15 pm on January 12, 2004. According to unsealed court documents, witnesses saw Calkins put Williams in the back of his car and drive away. Theres two 911 calls, one of her saying he was threatening to shoot her, which got cut off. That didnt happen until 2009. Seay, a legal expert who is not affiliated with the case, says the attorneys representing Williams family would have had an opportunity to argue the case during trial if they filed their motion in time. Naples, Fla. On January 11, 2004, when Terrance Williams handed over some gas money and said, "I'll see you later, momma," his mother Marcia did not realize that it would be the last time she'd see her son. He maintains a low profile and has refrained from making details of his private life as well as his current location public knowledge. CEDAR RAPIDS - A Cedar Rapids man who is a former Florida sheriff's deputy being sued by the family of a man who went missing in 2004 after a traffic stop may face a civil jury trial if a judge doesn't accept a recent arbitration decision. Calkins attorney, John Hooley, said during a civil court proceeding that enough is enough. A judge has set a hearing on the motions for Feb. 18 in Collier County. Former deputy Steven Calkins is believed to be the last person to see Felipe Santos and Terrance Williams before their disappearances in 2003 and 2004, respectively, according to the. In short order, she received a call from the local Mexican consulate. Benjamin Crump, the civil rights attorney representing the family of Terrance Williams, said the legal filing was the culmination of more than a decade of investigative work with the cooperation of the Collier county sheriffs office, and would compel Calkins to explain his actions in a formal deposition. She wasnt able to elaborate on what happened that night in 1997, but said she has planned a meeting with Denson and his attorney. Ryan Watson Jr. is accused of killing Daniel Rodriguez-Lopez, 17, during a shooting on Saturday, according to the Arcadia Police Department. Terrance Williams' family filed a wrongful death lawsuit against Steve Calkins, a former Collier County deputy. The Collier County Sheriffs Office has released a composite sketch of a man sought in connection with distraction theft suspects who are targeting senior citizens for their jewelry. Specifically, he was 49 when he captured Terrance Williams on January 12, 2004. Calkins' Naples attorney, John Hooley, declined to comment but did point out the arbitration decision in November found there is a lack of evidence in the case. The episode follows the investigation process and helps the viewers comprehend all the details. According to the lawsuit, Steven H. Calkins, now 66, came to Cedar Rapids years after the 2003 and 2004 cases in which two men went missing after being placed in the back of his patrol vehicle.. But no new evidence cropped up that could help find either Terrance or Felipe. When Crump's attorneys. France, 2011. Like in Williams' case, Calkins said he dropped Santos off at a Circle K in Naples. Marcia Williams remembers how, in the immediate aftermath of her son Terrance's disappearance, she and other family members launched an intensive search around Naples. By rejecting non-essential cookies, Reddit may still use certain cookies to ensure the proper functionality of our platform. In December 2020, Crump filed a motion for reconsideration and a new trial but was denied on appeal in January 2022. Witnesses told investigators they saw Calkins pat down Williams and place him in the back of his patrol car without handcuffs. Lee County announced that several beach parksLynn Hall Memorial Park, San Carlos Bay-Bunche Beach Preserve, Bonita Beach Park and Bonita Beach Accesses 1 to 10would reopen on Saturday. Are They Dead or Alive. Several witnesses had seen Steve at the Naples Memorial Cemetery with Terrance and saw him get into Steves patrol car. Two years later, in December 2020, Calkins was compelled as part of the civil suit to sit for a four-and-a-half-hour deposition, excerpts of which are included in the Paramount+ series "Never Seen Again." Asks for it back. Steven Calkins gives a deposition in 2020 "Never Seen Again"/Paramount+ A court appointed arbitrator ultimately ruled against the lawsuit, citing a lack of evidence. When Crump's attorneys missed a filing deadline to take the suit to trial, the judge sided with the arbitrator, dismissing the case. While an investigation cleared Steves name, Felipes family suspected foul play. Judge denies motion to dismiss lawsuit against former Collier County deputy, Winds stoke brush fires and prompt evacuations across Southwest Florida, Fort Myers High School hosts annual unified basketball game, Public adjuster answers your hurricane-related property insurance questions, What the number of winter shorebirds means for Florida, Collier County deputies seek man connected to distraction theft suspects, Woman accused of killing Charlotte County deputy in DUI crash denied bond for second time, Deputies investigating deadly crash, unrelated shooting in Collier County, Deputies investigating shooting at Collier County Waffle House, How bloodless open heart surgeries are performed, North Naples woman arrested after dog dies trapped in vehicle, After Hurricane Ian, Lee County reopening beach parks with free parking, Public memorial for Fort Myers Police Chief Derrick Diggs. Are They Dead or Alive? No refunds for partial months. Reporter covering state and federal courts. He was fired from the Collier County Sheriffs Office in late 2004 following an internal investigation that found he was deceptive in a polygraph and gave inconsistent statements about Williams disappearance. A former Collier County Sheriff's deputy, then Corporal Steve Calkins, is believed to be the last person to see both of the men. However, because some of his surviving victims were still in the closet and therefore unwilling to out themselves by testifying against him, he was never charged and to this day his name has never been released. ThatEnglishKid, Susan Powell. All rights reserved. After free month period, subscription automatically renews on a monthly or annual basis and your credit card automatically charged either (I) US $4.99 or $9.99/month (+ tax) as applicable; or (II) $49.99 or $99.99/year (+ tax) as applicable, at the start of each billing period unless you cancel.